Lubna Kably and Madhavi Rajadhyaksha | March 30, 2013A hole-in-the-wall cramped with 30 toddlers passes off as a playschool. A drawing room in an apartment building is converted into a creche from 9 am to 6 pm. An anganwadi in a rural hamlet has no choice but to send its tiny tots outdoors every time they want to pee, for want of an indoor toilet.
The early childhood care and education (ECCE) sector in India which determines the future of over 16 crore children below six years of age - an age group scientifically proven to be the crucial formative years for socio-emotional and cognitiveintellectual development lasting into adulthood - has largely been operating as a cottage industry of sorts. Even the Right to Education Policy has left out this age group.
This free run, especially by unscrupulous players is set to end with the Ministry of Women and Child Development introducing a draft ECCE policy. The draft spells out minimum quality standards that playschools, creches, anganwadis and nurseries (both government and private players) should follow in order to earn a government stamp of accreditation.
The quality standards are wide-ranging, and in the process of accreditation weightages will be given to parameters such as the physical environment (such as available space, drinking water and toilet facilities); adult supervision (with an adult-child ratio prescription ); and teacher's qualifications, to name a few.
In addition, the draft ECCE policy outlines a common curriculum framework that would guide preschools on age-specific developmental parameters for children. For instance, children below three should be engaged in free play or those above four could be initiated into writing from left to right. Many countries, including developing countries, have similar norms in place, which often are mandatory for all players in the ECCE segment (see box). India's ECCE draft policy is at a nascent stage but debates about its feasibility are already raging. After all, the sector is marked by wide disparity, ranging from free-of-cost state-run anganwadis to a handful of pre-schools boasting world class standards and international affiliations, albeit at a hefty price.
Is it then fair to paint all private and public preschools with the same brush? Are the standards proposed by the ministry apace with real-time constraints of space, staff and infrastructure? Is such government regulation warranted at all? The jury is still out.
Sujata Sriram, core member of the Association for Early Childhood Education and Development, believes the quality norms are absolutely essential. She states: "Until recently, ECCE wasn't seen as lucrative as higher education, but private players are now mushrooming. Many are milking the public and there is absolutely no accountability."
The standards in question lay down certain 'non-negotiable' conditions. For instance, the draft requires that a classroom accommodating 30 children be at least 35 square metres in area and provide 30 sq m of outdoor space. It also mandates separate toilets for boys and girls.
Rajesh Bhatia, founder and managing director of Tree House which provides pre-school education across India, welcomes quality standards but believes some aspects need to be pondered over. "Such space norms might be feasible in Kolhapur, for instance, but are not practical for a city like Mumbai, " he says, pointing out that higher education school boards such as CBSE and ICSE have different spatial norms for metros and other cities, a pragmatic approach which should be adopted by the ECCE as well.
"There is a crying need for improving standards in the ECCE segment. Yet, regulations in any form must not deter those private players who wish to provide the best global standards, " states Arun Arora, chairman, Edvance Pre-schools, which in collaboration with Eton House of Singapore, has set up 40 preschools across India.
"If certain quality standards are to be introduced, such as a minimum space requirement, it is also essential that the government must act as a facilitator. For instance, in some congested areas of Mumbai, space is just not available. Here government land could be made available for nurturing the ECCE segment. Credit lines at differential rates of interest would give this sector a huge boost, " adds Arora.
The draft ECCE policy also stipulates that service providers in the ECCE segment follow an adult-child ratio of 1:20 in the 3- to 6-year age group, and 1:10 ratio for under three-year-olds. It highlights the need for teacher's education, even as it doesn't spell out the minimum qualifications.
But can this really be implemented given our shortage of trained staff? Reeta Sonawat, executive director of the Early Childhood Association in India (ECA-India ) admits that we have a shortage of teachers at all levels. "But we don't compromise in high school with teachers who lack basic BEd degrees. Then why compromise on quality in the ECCE segment?" she asks.
Swati Popat Vats, President ECA, states: "Let's understand that a minimum one-year qualification with at least 600 hours of hands-on-internship is a must. The ECA is against the three-month courses that are now thriving."
To account for the wide disparity in the educational background of ECCE teachers, teachers at Edvance for instance, are classified into categories. "Much of what they have learnt has to be unlearnt, and on-the-job training in addition to formal training via workshops is vital. It could take anything from a year or more to go from being a trainee teacher to the next level, " explains Arora. Sriram also believes that innovative methods such as peer tutoring and cooperative training could be adopted to plug this major lacuna in the system.
There are, of course, those who question the very rationale of regulation, arguing that it has failed to inject quality into higher education. They say the mechanism of accreditation will create corruption. "First, let's set up a policy and see how it will work. After all, ECCE service providers have been offered the choice of following the accreditation norms, " sums up Sriram. It's left to be seen how many make the move.
Many countries have quality norms in place with special emphasis on teacher training. For instance, in Sweden training and qualifications provided to ECCE and school teachers are unified under a single scheme. They all undergo at least three and a half years of training, with the first year comprising a common core module. The aim is to make education seamless, starting from preschool. Singapore has a common training programme and minimum qualifications for teachers across all child care centres (for ages 2 months to 6 years) and preschools (for ages 4 to 6 years). Licenses to private players are granted by the government and inspection visits are undertaken periodically. 'Te-Whariki', which in Maori suggests a woven mat for all to stand on, describes the holistic approach to ECCE in New Zealand, which begins at birth and continues until the age of enrolment in formal education.
A range of requirements are carved out for ECCE programmes relating to health and safety, staffing (ratios and qualifications), facilities, and so on. The level of funding given by the MoE to those providing these services (mainly community-run NGOs) depends on these criteria. In a developing country like Brazil, to ensure quality standards, ECCE programmes run by municipalities - and comprising of daycare centres (0-3 years) and preschools (4 to 6 years) - fall within the administrative purview of the Education Ministry.
Early Childhood Association - Interview with Ms. Swati Popat Vats
The Early years of a child's life are indeed the foundational years... everyone associated with early childhood wants to safeguard childhood, to give children their rights, to make available for our teachers, be it in balwadis or International schools and parents the best international research about child development and learning.
10 point advisory to parents in selecting a quality daycare / crèche / babysitting 10 point advisory to Day Cares and Crèches from Early Childhood Association ECA Member: Age Criteria 2016
10 point advisory to parents in selecting a quality daycare / crèche / babysitting
Do not choose a daycare just because it is cheap. They may be saving on salaries by not appointing proper or enough number of staff.
Check the credentials of the people/person running the daycare.
Just having CCTV cameras is not enough, ask the daycare if they check the recordings, and how regularly, also check if parents can check past recordings.
Ask them about the training given to staff.
Find out if all staff are police verified and medically free from contagious diseases.
Does the daycare have an emergency handling procedure.
Are staff trained in basic first aid like handling choking etc or do they have a nurse on the premise or doctor on call.
Do they have regular fire drills.
If food is being served then check hygiene of the kitchen and the person who cooks. If food is brought from a caterer or supplier check the suitability of this vendor.
Check hygiene of toilets.
Please ensure that you give training to all your staff especially support staff like bais about the do’s and don’ts’s of handling children. Training must include how to handle children, how not to handle children, washing hands before touching children, wearing gloves when feeding them, tying up hair while cooking or serving, not to blow on a child’s food to cool it , to use separate cloths for cleaning floors, tables, and wiping children’s mouth or bottoms. (you are free to contact us for more details)
During the training it is important to mention to them that handling children will be done as per the training given to them and not as per their family practices.
At the end of the training make them sign a letter that states all the points of training and also states that if they are caught breaking any rules then they will lose their job and if found abusing children will be handed to the police.
Get all bais and other support staff registered at the nearest police station for police verification.
Get bais and support staff tested for HIV, TB and other important diseases.
Children should never be left alone with bais and support staff unsupervised.
Check CCTV footage of new bais daily to understand how they are with kids in your absence.
If a parent comes to you with a complaint against any of your staff, never cover up for them, this will only make them break more rules.
Pay your staff well so that they are able to fulfill their duties diligently.
Do look into the adult–child ratio of your daycare as putting too many children in the care of one adult can cause stress and make them break rules.
We urge all Early Childhood Association member schools to please ensure that for nursery admissions for academic year 2016-17, to please follow age criteria of child completing 3 Years by July 31st, 2016. Also please note states like Maharashtra, Telangana, Tamil Nadu and territories like Delhi have started to strictly implement the same and other states and territories will soon follow.